SDNA

SD NEWS AGENCY {A part of LVGC – Luniya Vinayak Group of Compnies)

SDNA

SD NEWS AGENCY {A part of LVGC – Luniya Vinayak Group of Compnies)

Madhya PradeshCentral Zone STATES

Journalists Raise Alarm Over Growing Politics of Dominance in Democracy; National Discussion Examines the Roles of Government, Opposition and Media

Senior journalists warn that weakening public opinion threatens democratic foundations; freedom of expression, independent journalism and a strong opposition are essential for a healthy democracy

(SDNA) Special Report

Indore. The strength of a democracy rests on the voice of its people, freedom of thought and the impartial functioning of constitutional institutions. However, the growing tension between public opinion, public welfare and the pursuit of political dominance has raised serious concerns. Against this backdrop, the State Press Club, Madhya Pradesh, organised a national discussion on the theme, “Politics of Dominance in Democracy: Where Is Public Opinion and How Much Public Welfare?”

Held at the Abhinav Kala Samaj Auditorium in Indore, the programme brought together prominent journalists and political analysts from across the country. Speakers examined the challenges facing public expression and dissent, drawing comparisons between the Emergency period and the contemporary political environment.

📢 Join SD News Agency and Get Every News Update on Your Mobile!

Stay updated with the latest and important news from India and around the world, including politics, society, business, state and local news, delivered directly to your mobile phone via WhatsApp.

📰 Join the SD News Agency WhatsApp Group by clicking the link below and stay connected with the latest updates.

👉 Click here to join the WhatsApp Group:
Join SD News Agency WhatsApp Group

SD News Agency — News that matters to you.

Ashutosh: Organised propaganda is influencing public thinking

Ashutosh, founder of ‘Satya Hindi’ and a senior journalist, said that organised propaganda was being used to influence how people think and understand issues. He expressed concern that citizens’ ability to think independently and question developments was being weakened, creating an atmosphere in which people were increasingly expected to accept whatever they were told as the truth.

Describing the situation as resembling a kind of “digital arrest”, he said that India was frequently portrayed as a superpower and a world leader, while the ground reality required a more critical assessment. He added that society might one day have to reflect deeply on the prevailing narrative and reconsider its assumptions.

Ashutosh alleged that the forces currently in power were pursuing politics of dominance and attempting to eliminate those who challenged their authority. He emphasised that dissent is indispensable to democracy. Referring to the early years after Independence, he recalled that Dr. B. R. Ambedkar and Mahatma Gandhi had openly differed on constitutional questions, while Pandit Shyama Prasad Mukherjee was included in the Nehru Cabinet. Despite ideological differences, leaders of that era shared the objective of taking the country forward.

In contrast, he said, concerns were now being raised over pressure on the Opposition and media, as well as growing political interference in constitutional institutions.

He further remarked that a country shaped by the traditions of Lord Ram and Kabir should have no place for mob lynching. People who raise questions, he said, should be heard rather than sent behind bars.

Indore’s rich journalistic legacy highlighted; newspapers urged to welcome diverse viewpoints

Ashutosh described Indore as a city with a distinguished journalistic tradition. He remembered eminent journalists and editors such as Rahul Barpute, Rajendra Mathur and Prabhash Joshi, whose contributions gave a new direction to language journalism. Hindi journalism, he said, would always remain indebted to their legacy.

He stressed that journalism remains incomplete if democratic values and diversity of opinion are absent within a newspaper itself. People representing different ideologies must have the freedom and opportunity to express their views through its pages.

Vinod Agnihotri questions media practices and stresses government accountability

Vinod Agnihotri, advisor-editor of ‘Amar Ujala’ and a political analyst, said that public opinion develops through ideas, debate and struggle. However, he felt that the process was being weakened in the present political environment.

Referring to the Emergency imposed in 1975 under Indira Gandhi, he observed that even a strong government could undermine democratic freedoms. He described the present central government as strong and expressed the view that the country was witnessing conditions resembling an undeclared Emergency.

He noted that neither Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru nor Indira Gandhi had advocated a country without an Opposition. However, political slogans such as ‘Congress-free’ and ‘Opposition-free’ had become part of contemporary political discourse.

Questioning the media’s role, Agnihotri said that actions which were allegedly unconstitutional were sometimes presented and promoted as ‘masterstrokes’. He urged journalists to examine how the language used by the media shapes public understanding.

Citing the 1974 JP Movement, he recalled that the agitation had also been portrayed as being influenced by foreign forces. He said that even today, protests at Jantar Mantar were sometimes linked to alleged foreign conspiracies, but the identity of those supposed foreign forces remained an unanswered question.

Agnihotri also spoke about the influence of public pressure on democratic institutions. Referring to the Supreme Court’s scrutiny of the Election Commission and the subsequent reconsideration of certain decisions, he said that public opinion played an important role in ensuring accountability. Citing the Bhagirathpura episode in Indore, he observed that public pressure had helped bring the issue into the national spotlight.

He stressed that democratic institutions must be respected, the Opposition must remain strong and the media must fulfil its responsibility. Journalism, he said, should not be limited to promoting government achievements; it must consistently raise public concerns and ensure that the Opposition’s role in a democracy remains meaningful.

He also expressed concern that attacks on journalists often fail to receive adequate national attention. The media, he said, must continue raising its voice against such incidents.

Jaishankar Gupta: Politics of dominance is affecting democratic institutions

Jaishankar Gupta, executive editor of ‘Deshbandhu’ and a political analyst, said that people criticising the government or speaking uncomfortable truths were increasingly being subjected to the fear of investigative agencies such as the ED and CBI, as well as the threat of imprisonment.

He argued that politics of dominance was affecting the independence of various pillars of democracy.

Referring to Indira Gandhi’s tenure and the Emergency, Gupta also commented on Narendra Modi’s political rise and the present style of governance. He said that the Morarji Desai government had made it extremely difficult to misuse constitutional provisions relating to the imposition of an Emergency. However, he alleged that new methods were now being used to create conditions resembling an undeclared Emergency.

Raising concerns over parliamentary functioning, Gupta said that the Opposition’s objections and voices were not receiving adequate consideration, while bills were being passed rapidly. He also expressed concern over appointments in the judiciary, emphasising that public confidence in the independence and impartiality of judicial institutions must be protected.

Recalling the political atmosphere of five decades ago, Gupta said that opposition parties regularly protested against governments, but dissent was not always suppressed. Even members of ruling parties sometimes raised legitimate demands against their own governments, and their views were respected.

He emphasised that disagreement and political opposition should never be treated as hostility in a democratic system.

Discussion on Jaishankar Gupta’s book ‘From Emergency to Amrit Kaal’

The discussion also featured the recently published book ‘Aapatkal Se Amritkal’ (From Emergency to Amrit Kaal) by senior journalist Jaishankar Gupta. The book examines the 21 months of the Emergency and offers an extensive discussion of political developments during Narendra Modi’s current tenure.

Members of the audience actively participated in the session, raising questions on media impartiality, the functioning of the Election Commission, government policies, Sanatan traditions and Hindutva. The speakers responded to the questions and shared their perspectives on the issues.

Journalists and distinguished guests participate in the programme

At the beginning of the event, State Press Club, Madhya Pradesh president Praveen Khariwal, Rachna Johri, Dr. Rais Qureshi, Adil Saeed, Ismail Lahari, Sonali Yadav, Sanjeev Shrivastava and Sunil Jain welcomed the guests.

The programme was conducted by Sanjeev Shrivastava and Pankaj Kshirsagar. The invited speakers and guests were presented with creative literature and mementoes by the State Press Club, Madhya Pradesh. The event concluded with a vote of thanks delivered by chief general secretary Navneet Shukla.

The national discussion brought the focus back to some of the fundamental requirements of a healthy democracy: independent journalism, accountable governance, an effective Opposition and respect for dissent. The speakers underlined that public welfare and public opinion can remain balanced only when the people’s voice continues to occupy a central place in democratic governance.

(SDNA) Special Report

blank
blank
blank

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *